Thursday, 9 November 2017

To The Bone: Ethical Issues

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2017/jun/26/netflix-to-the-bone-anorexic-mental-health-eating-disorders-iliy-collins

To The Bone is a Netflix original series and it is about a young women dealing with anorexia. She meets an unconventional doctor who challenges her to face condition and embrace life.


Image result for to the bone


  • Mental health experts have said that this Netflix original could trigger serious psychological issues for sufferers and should come with a warning.
  • Netflix recently was at the centre of controversy over its series '13 reasons why', because it was a portrayal of a teenagers suicide that critics said could encourage young people to kill themselves. Psychiatrists have said that 'To the bone' has similar criticisms. 
  • To the bone is potentially risky to two groups of people including those who have not yet developed an eating disorder and just the risk of glamorising it. 

  • There have been calls to ban the film because of the fears that the film may promote eating disorders. 
  • Viewers that may suffer with eating disordering may be in a vulnerable state to the power of the media and some of the images in the film. 
  • There is a debate over 'To the bone' that girls can be infected with anorexia by looking at images of slim (starved) bodies which is where anorexia lies. 
  • There are objections to "To The Bone claim"  that it glamorises anorexia and stereotypes of going girls.
  • The chair of the eating disorders faculty at the Royal College of psychiatrists Dasha Nicholls said that her "main message for people who will be vulnerable to this is to consume with caution." She also said that a trigger warning would be a sensible idea as well a parental advisory note. 

  • Psychologist Dr Carolyn Keenan said that " it is possible that some viewers may find the content distressing and triggering and netflix and viewers will need to take responsibility for what they do with that. 
  • Some of the images in the trailer could trigger emotional distress in those with anorexia because the main character counts calories and looks extremely thin.\
  • There is a lot of concern about the use of imagery from patient and carer groups. 

However even though there are so many ethical issues, a lot of people also support the media in raising awareness of eating disorders however can trigger negative behaviours in people who are affected by there mental health issues. 

1 comment:

  1. Fantastic research conducted in relation to your chosen film. Well done!

    ReplyDelete

Concept Art

Zayne music video - Compare the concept art to the real thing: Graphics are very similar to the concept art Same retro colors  Lots of ...